TOPIC: Wife/GF/SO Girth thread Continuation

I think the best test for Girth size may be the following: Some how (may be a woman who is willing to have sex with two different guys at the same time but she can\'t see their faces or bodies) have a woman have sex with a 4.5 Inch Girth penis or dildo, now have the same woman have sex with a 6 Inch Girth penis/dildo....I almost guarantee she will like the 6 Inch better! one has to take all other variables out of the experiment.

PMMA someday soon wrote: I read somewhere that 7.5 x 5.5 was the most popular dildo size amongst women purchasing from sex shops.

That\'s actually quite pleasant to hear/read because a woman would still have to be holding the dildo which means she\'s only inserting 4-5\" of actual length (similar to how long porn stars experience \"dry Dick\" because they can\'t/don\'t insert all the way). Perhaps a reassuring thing to note for us shorter guys

HunkChunk wrote: @eqstudent
How many really can accomodate 8\" length?
Do they insert them all the way, or was some length preference used to account for hand placement?
HC

I strongly suspect (especially since the bulk of these women probably have not seen a real 8-incher, or at best, seen them very infrequently) long dildos/vibrators are made to be long to allow for the palm of the woman to be taken into account. And even in most pornography I decided to review (a horrible resource indeed), many of the non-freakish type women typically inserted 5-6 inches of the actual toy into them. There is a chance the women themselves in these studies were entirely oblivious that an 8-Inch toy was designed as such for the purpose of providing hand-held space. The same women who probably couldn\'t eyeball a size or accurately gauge their past lovers dimensions.
Furthermore, if 5-6\" is sufficient, that is explains why dildos & vibrators are not just as long...because once a woman gets her hand around a 6\" dildo, she only has 3\" (+/-) of insertable toy.
At novelty sex stores, I\'ve come to notice dildos that were 6\" or so were usually the mountable kind... the one\'s meant to stay stationery (by means of suction cup or whatever) so that the woman would not be using her hand and she would be using the toy in free form. Otherwise, all hand-insertables were almost always longer than 5-6\".
This may be of some comfort to us \"shorter\" guys. I\'ve also concluded before that 5.5\"-6.5\" may be the ideal length if the same individual had a massive Girth. This is because with that length, one could fuck Balls deep (thus allowing the base of the penis to maximize entry & clitoral stimulation) without necessarily pounding the cervix. So in other words, a 6x6 might actually be more ideal than the fabled 8x6. At least in my judgment, which is only so good since I\'m not a woman lol.

@eqstudent
That is some interesting info with the sweetspot being between 4.5\" and 5.5\" in Girth. I find that comforting to most of us, although I\'m sure that the fellow who got the world\'s record PMMA enhancement would question their choice of a proportioned dildo when their fridge is filled with coke cans?
How many really can accomodate 8\" length? I\'ve seen lots of porn scenes in which the girl looked like she couldn\'t take that much in and actually suffered when a longish guy got tired of the dry Dick syndrome and tried to penetrate them further... Did you ask them about other length preferences?
A few other things coms to mind. Did they try them out or just react to their feel and appearance? Do they insert them all the way, or was some length preference used to account for hand placement? Also, were they each alone to cast a private vote or did they choose in front of each other? I wonder about peer pressure and also the reliability of a size preference for an artificial item which probably would fail to dilate them upon penetration as much as the turn on of a HOT guy straight out of the PhalloBoard forum.
HC

I dont have 8 inches and mine is too thick....Nobody wants me mvahhh

PMMA someday soon wrote: Is it a possiblity that women are avoiding the very large dildoes not because they are sub-optimal but to avoid adjusting to a size they are less likely to find in real life?

Impossible to say, but I doubt it. We can only guess here so my conjecture would be that they are indeed going for optimal size (they are buying something to provide pleasure - why cut themselves short?). Also note that vibrators in particular remain permanently Erect whereas a real penis can fluctuate in Erection quality. Its rigidity may mean that a vibrator requires less sheer Girth (just a theory).
The 5\" - 5.5\" Erect Girth range can accommodate a Magnum condom, so I\'d imagine they should suffice for most normal, healthy women.
A part of me wonders if we should have a Resident-Female board member here who can be verified and who can be entrusted with providing valuable insight and who isn\'t a dreaded size queen. It would almost certainly have to be someone\'s wife, and I can\'t imagine how comfortable any of the guys would be with entertaining this idea. We do have 2 female members as far as I know, one who has posted but hasn\'t posted for a while. A part of me wants to keep this place strictly male, but then apart of me realizes that we sometimes discuss things (like this topic) with no real certainty of the answers unless female input is provided (which eqstudent has so graciously provided).
Anyways, I hope to break 5\" EG across the entire shaft after Round 3.

Is it a possiblity that women are avoiding the very large dildoes not because they are sub-optimal but to avoid adjusting to a size they are less likely to find in real life?

You might want to stretch in an attempt to gain length before contemplating PMMA. I would stretch for a minimum of 6 months first.

Ahhh good news! I think I know what I might be doing after my Ligamentolysis

I would think so KFH. Using 20%, most definitely.

This is a pretty unrelated question, but if I wanted say, only 0.3\" - 0.6\" of gain in Girth, would one round of PMMA suffice?

eq, thanks for the new info! This is one of my favorite threads, really puts desirable Girth into perspective!

Good work eqstudent!

Third meet a few weeks ago. There were 28 women inattendance between the ages of 24 and 42. The results are as follows:Length Girth Votes
8' smaller 0
8' 4.0' 1
8' 4.5' 4
8' 5.0' 14
8' 5.5' 8
8' 6.0' 1
8' larger 0 Cumulative Totals of 71womenLength Girth Votes
8' smaller 0
8' 4.0' 2
8' 4.5' 9
8' 5.0' 35
8' 5.5' 21
8' 6.0' 3
8' larger 1 Hanging out after the meet the woman who runs the parties commented that she sells much bigger dildos to couples than to women bythemselve

PMMAsomeday soon wrote: I read somewhere that 7.5 x 5.5 was the most popular dildo sizeamongst women purchasing from sex shops.

Must have been on a PE site The most popular dildo according to the woman who runs the parties isthe 'rabbit' which is < 3.5' in Girth.Hereis a search for best-selling dildoshttp://www.sh-womenstore.com/Sex+Toys/Dildo+Delights/Best+Selling+Dildos.htmyoucan see most are < 5' in Girth.