Had my 100% of my ligs cut year and a half ago. No regrets.
I do feel that the doctors technique and procedure plays a huge role in your outcome. Any doc can take your money, cut you open, cut your ligs and sew you back up again. Its the doctors with the expereince, the proper technique, good communication, spend the time to explain things and are honest about the expectations that make all the difference.
If you are 6\" plus in length, dont consider the procedure. I had a good experience but results may vary.