TOPIC: 5 years post PMMA...regrets

I think the max increase in Girth should be 25-30 percent . 5 can got to 6.3 .... more creates aesthetic issues but primarily when Flaccid .

I approach 7.5 now when really hard and my experience is that any women can handle that if she is turned on . And it feels amazing to her . Just my experience .

Dthom wrote: I think the max increase in Girth should be 25-30 percent . 5 can got to 6.3 .... more creates aesthetic issues but primarily when Flaccid .

I approach 7.5 now when really hard and my experience is that any women can handle that if she is turned on . And it feels amazing to her . Just my experience .

How many sessions/CC do you have Dthom? Didn't you get Ellanse? I read your thread on the old board now and I think you were in the 6.5 range then at the end... I don't know how to search for members posts on the new board.

Dthom wrote: I think the max increase in Girth should be 25-30 percent . 5 can got to 6.3 .... more creates aesthetic issues but primarily when Flaccid .

I approach 7.5 now when really hard and my experience is that any women can handle that if she is turned on . And it feels amazing to her . Just my experience .

7.5 Girth and any girl can handle it?? WTF mate sorry but that can´t be true, youre probably one of the 1000 thickestt guys in the world with that Girth

Dthom wrote: I think the max increase in Girth should be 25-30 percent . 5 can got to 6.3 .... more creates aesthetic issues but primarily when Flaccid .

I approach 7.5 now when really hard and my experience is that any women can handle that if she is turned on . And it feels amazing to her . Just my experience .

You sound crazy bro. I actually think you should step away from the forum. Telling guys this creates a terrible precedent. Especially for younger guys here that are impressionable. Even the biggest natural guy isn’t 7.5” around. Don’t any woman alive need or want a 7.5” Girth penis to feel pleasure unless they are into fisting or extreme toy sizes and that’s definitely not the average woman and a very small Niche of women that’s into that type of stuff.

New1inch wrote:

Dthom wrote: I think the max increase in girth should be 25-30 percent . 5 can got to 6.3 .... more creates aesthetic issues but primarily when flaccid .

I approach 7.5 now when really hard and my experience is that any women can handle that if she is turned on . And it feels amazing to her . Just my experience .

You sound crazy bro. I actually think you should step away from the forum. Telling guys this creates a terrible precedent. Especially for younger guys here that are impressionable. Even the biggest natural guy isn’t 7.5” around. Don’t any woman alive need or want a 7.5” girth penis to feel pleasure unless they are into fisting or extreme toy sizes and that’s definitely not the average woman and a very small Niche of women that’s into that type of stuff.

Hey New1inch, long time no see. I just want to remind you and everyone to refrain from name calling (example: "crazy", etc) when it isn't warranted. We can disagree, express disappointment, or enlighten the individual, but taking a shot at their psyche wont help change minds or attitudes.

For example, you could have pointed out the rarity of girths that big, the diminishing returns many other men have reported with girths north of 6", and the importance of being mindful of one's audience (e.g. "young and impressionable guys"). You could have said all that and avoided the "you're crazy, take a forum break" kind of comments. Leave that to the Moderators

Glad to see you're still around regardless and hope all is well. You don't have to respond to this (you can PM me if you'd like), and I ask everyone to resume the topic. Thanks.
.

Skeptical_One wrote:

New1inch wrote:

Dthom wrote: I think the max increase in girth should be 25-30 percent . 5 can got to 6.3 .... more creates aesthetic issues but primarily when flaccid .

I approach 7.5 now when really hard and my experience is that any women can handle that if she is turned on . And it feels amazing to her . Just my experience .

You sound crazy bro. I actually think you should step away from the forum. Telling guys this creates a terrible precedent. Especially for younger guys here that are impressionable. Even the biggest natural guy isn’t 7.5” around. Don’t any woman alive need or want a 7.5” girth penis to feel pleasure unless they are into fisting or extreme toy sizes and that’s definitely not the average woman and a very small Niche of women that’s into that type of stuff.

Hey New1inch, long time no see. I just want to remind you and everyone to refrain from name calling (example: "crazy", etc) when it isn't warranted. We can disagree, express disappointment, or enlighten the individual, but taking a shot at their psyche wont help change minds or attitudes.

For example, you could have pointed out the rarity of girths that big, the diminishing returns many other men have reported with girths north of 6", and the importance of being mindful of one's audience (e.g. "young and impressionable guys"). You could have said all that and avoided the "you're crazy, take a forum break" kind of comments. Leave that to the Moderators

Glad to see you're still around regardless and hope all is well. You don't have to respond to this (you can PM me if you'd like), and I ask everyone to resume the topic. Thanks.
.

This is wise moderation. Thanks SO.

Skeptical_One wrote:

New1inch wrote:

Dthom wrote: I think the max increase in girth should be 25-30 percent . 5 can got to 6.3 .... more creates aesthetic issues but primarily when flaccid .

I approach 7.5 now when really hard and my experience is that any women can handle that if she is turned on . And it feels amazing to her . Just my experience .

You sound crazy bro. I actually think you should step away from the forum. Telling guys this creates a terrible precedent. Especially for younger guys here that are impressionable. Even the biggest natural guy isn’t 7.5” around. Don’t any woman alive need or want a 7.5” girth penis to feel pleasure unless they are into fisting or extreme toy sizes and that’s definitely not the average woman and a very small Niche of women that’s into that type of stuff.

Hey New1inch, long time no see. I just want to remind you and everyone to refrain from name calling (example: "crazy", etc) when it isn't warranted. We can disagree, express disappointment, or enlighten the individual, but taking a shot at their psyche wont help change minds or attitudes.

For example, you could have pointed out the rarity of girths that big, the diminishing returns many other men have reported with girths north of 6", and the importance of being mindful of one's audience (e.g. "young and impressionable guys"). You could have said all that and avoided the "you're crazy, take a forum break" kind of comments. Leave that to the Moderators

Glad to see you're still around regardless and hope all is well. You don't have to respond to this (you can PM me if you'd like), and I ask everyone to resume the topic. Thanks.
.

I understand that as a Mod you have to calm down waters, however sometimes true has to be said. And we all know that even guys with 5.5" to 6" girth have had problems at sometime, and this guy out of nowhere says everything is fine with a 7.5" Girth!! Even in Porn you can count with your hand the number of guys with this kind of thickness.

fightclub wrote:

Skeptical_One wrote:

New1inch wrote:

Dthom wrote: I think the max increase in girth should be 25-30 percent . 5 can got to 6.3 .... more creates aesthetic issues but primarily when flaccid .

I approach 7.5 now when really hard and my experience is that any women can handle that if she is turned on . And it feels amazing to her . Just my experience .

You sound crazy bro. I actually think you should step away from the forum. Telling guys this creates a terrible precedent. Especially for younger guys here that are impressionable. Even the biggest natural guy isn’t 7.5” around. Don’t any woman alive need or want a 7.5” girth penis to feel pleasure unless they are into fisting or extreme toy sizes and that’s definitely not the average woman and a very small Niche of women that’s into that type of stuff.

Hey New1inch, long time no see. I just want to remind you and everyone to refrain from name calling (example: "crazy", etc) when it isn't warranted. We can disagree, express disappointment, or enlighten the individual, but taking a shot at their psyche wont help change minds or attitudes.

For example, you could have pointed out the rarity of girths that big, the diminishing returns many other men have reported with girths north of 6", and the importance of being mindful of one's audience (e.g. "young and impressionable guys"). You could have said all that and avoided the "you're crazy, take a forum break" kind of comments. Leave that to the Moderators

Glad to see you're still around regardless and hope all is well. You don't have to respond to this (you can PM me if you'd like), and I ask everyone to resume the topic. Thanks.
.

I understand that as a Mod you have to calm down waters, however sometimes true has to be said. And we all know that even guys with 5.5" to 6" girth have had problems at sometime, and this guy out of nowhere says everything is fine with a 7.5" Girth!! Even in Porn you can count with your hand the number of guys with this kind of thickness.

I never said you couldn't make observations or offer your own opinions (I actually made that quite clear). The name-calling is where I raised an objection, and I was not challenging the actual meat & bones of the comment itself.

For what it's worth, a 7.5" girth is exceedingly rare and I'd never recommend it unless you know what it entails. Diminishing returns are a real thing; not only with sex, but aesthetics as well. Personally, I'd consider anything north of 5.5" mid-shaft circumference to be certifiably thick, and the average girth probably sits around 4.8" (I say "probably" since I'm relying largely on anecdotal evidence and a few sparse surveys). And even the thickest guys in porn seldom cross the 7" realm in girth save for a few industry freaks.

I also politely asked we resume the topic at hand, thanks.

1) I suggested that 25-30 percent was all that you should go . That would take one from 5.6 to 7.2 or so . Mine only gets up to 7.5 infrequently .

2) my experience is that women like it very much . As I said , that's my experience . In reading the board I don't believe people with about 7 have had a lot of problems. Conjecture by individuals who don't have that Girth is just that , conjecture .

As an example of real experience , I have a friend who is 5 1 and 105 lbs . She has no problems and she enjoys it immensely .

Again , more than 30 percent is not good aesthetically and I wish I had not needed the last touch up . Flaccid it can look like a pig in a blanket . But as far as women's enjoyment ? They seem to love it -- sample size about 10

To be fair, I think this is all subjective. Dthom could very well have met women that like this size.

I previously lived in a house-shares with lots of single women who told me all about their experiences meeting men on dating sites. A few drinks later and they even told me about the problems they have with "big dicks". trust me... I've heard stories! None of them would have handled anything over 6 inches Girth and they told me that they didn't enjoy the experience of being with some well endowed men, because it was painful and they needed to take it very slow.

However, I think it would be wrong to assume Dthom isn't telling the truth, because some people are in to stretching themselves and perhaps Dthom has simply being with women that had previously had children.

As Skeptical One said, 5.5 inches is probably best if you want the flexibility of ALL worlds (oral/pussy/anal) and anything above that will limit the potential diversity of your experiences in the future.
I agree that 5.5 inches is a good balance. Personally, if I go for 6 inches, I would do so knowing that I might have fewer options.

I would def agree that anal is out of the question . But these women by and large didn't have kids . Thickness is seldom an issue -- but length can hurt .

Dthom wrote: 1) I suggested that 25-30 percent was all that you should go . That would take one from 5.6 to 7.2 or so . Mine only gets up to 7.5 infrequently .

2) my experience is that women like it very much . As I said , that's my experience . In reading the board I don't believe people with about 7 have had a lot of problems. Conjecture by individuals who don't have that Girth is just that , conjecture .

As an example of real experience , I have a friend who is 5 1 and 105 lbs . She has no problems and she enjoys it immensely .

Again , more than 30 percent is not good aesthetically and I wish I had not needed the last touch up . Flaccid it can look like a pig in a blanket . But as far as women's enjoyment ? They seem to love it -- sample size about 10

Does it have the pig in a blanket look only when really retracted?

Liberati wrote: To be fair, I think this is all subjective. Dthom could very well have met women that like this size.

I previously lived in a house-shares with lots of single women who told me all about their experiences meeting men on dating sites. A few drinks later and they even told me about the problems they have with "big dicks". trust me... I've heard stories! None of them would have handled anything over 6 inches Girth and they told me that they didn't enjoy the experience of being with some well endowed men, because it was painful and they needed to take it very slow.

However, I think it would be wrong to assume Dthom isn't telling the truth, because some people are in to stretching themselves and perhaps Dthom has simply being with women that had previously had children.

As Skeptical One said, 5.5 inches is probably best if you want the flexibility of ALL worlds (oral/pussy/anal) and anything above that will limit the potential diversity of your experiences in the future.
I agree that 5.5 inches is a good balance. Personally, if I go for 6 inches, I would do so knowing that I might have fewer options.

I have to agree with what you said , the sweet spot is definitely around 5.5" to 5.75" , if you want to keep all 3 options in the table , with anal probably being the hardest one . Getting a BJ with a 6" Girth and the girl only be able to get an Inch past the head is not in my dreams.

Most can get far past the head -- the penis tapers toward the head down to 6 inches .

My point about 7 inches Girth was that women seem to like it a lot more than the 5.5 or so that I had before . Unless you have that type of Girth it's hard to speculate .

I am surprised there is such push back and skepticism . I was trying to contribute my experience and now I'm not believed ...

I'm at six inches of Girth now, and blowjobs really have been problematic at all. A little teeth now and then, but nothing major. In about eight weeks I'll find out how it is at 6.5.