Getsmart wrote: I've certainly read some, but it would be good to hear more since I think a lot of people are shy about it. Not asking for some kind of blow-by-blow (no pun intended) account of encounters--I'm not a voyeur or anything--but this is the category of "Vanity" after all.
As I mentioned in other threads, my wife and I are kind of swinger-y -- I guess that's how you'd put it -- so I've had a decent range of experiences with other women at swingers clubs, etc. After going to these places pre-PMMA and after, I'd say that the difference isn't quite as extreme as you might expect. The women who are truly after big dicks are in the minority. In fact, I'd say that there are just as many -- and perhaps more -- who try to avoid them. Most women truly don't seem to care about dick size. I rarely seen them gravitating to the big ones and avoiding the small ones.
That said, I have had some experiences where an increased size has been a factor. I've been complimented about it several times. After sex with one woman she exclaimed, "Oh my god he's big!" That felt kind of good to hear -- especially since she said it in front of a bunch of dudes who laughed and joked about it.
But then there's the flip side of legitimately being too big. In one situation it was clear that I was causing a considerable amount of discomfort. This isn't nearly as cool as you may think it would be before it happens. It's kind of unpleasent, actually, and makes you want to stop.
All that said, a bigger dick does physically feels better for me and I'd guess that it ultimately does feels better for most other women as well. But I may be a little biased here haha.